Police say a 43-year-old man - George Leodis of Mount Sinai - and a 25-year-old man - Michael Kontanis of Ridge were both charged with first-degree rape and criminal sex act in the attack at Fatty Beltbuckles in Rocky Point.
News 12 Long Island reports that Leodis is the owner of the establishment.
Suffolk County police did not immediately release further details about the May 14 attack.